Let's start with the voices, from high to low:
Female: soprano, mezzo soprano (or mezzo), contralto.
Male: countertenor, tenor, baritone, bass-baritone, bass.
Here are some examples:
Soprano Lucia Popp sings Die Holle Rache from Mozart's Die Zauberflote/ The Magic Flute (1791)
Mezzo-soprano Olga Borodina sings Mon coeur s'ouvre a ta voix from Saint-Saens's Samson and Delila (1877)
Countertenor Andreas Scholl sings Ombra mai fu from Handel's Xerxes (or Serse): also known as Handel's Largo (1738)
The countertenor voice is not a natural male voice: it is artificial. The singer has to go beyond his natural voice where his voice may break in order to reach this higher sound. If you can imagine a yodel, the higher notes are usually sung in falsetto. You can clearly hear the difference between the natural and falsetto voice in this rather marvellous clip of Franzl Lang yodelling:
In most operas of the Baroque period (roughly mid 17th-early 18th century) the hero was sung by a castrato: a boy castrated before puberty to keep his voice unnaturally high. The high voice would, though, have a certain masculine roughness to it but was also believed to be very pure. The castratos ruled opera for many decades and had many admirers for their combination of vocal purity and virility: the most celebrated was Farinelli. Nowadays, we tend not to castrate boys for them to sing opera, so the castrato roles are sung either by countertenors (though being a falsetto voice, they often lack the power to project in larger opera houses) or by mezzos/contraltos (who have to dress as men which can stretch credibility). The last known castrato was Alessandro Moreschi (1858-1922). Here he is in 1902 singing the Bach/Gounod Ave Maria. (This is not an easy listen. Whatever voice Moreschi may have had, he is clearly past his prime when recording this.)
Tenor Neil Shicoff sings Kuda, kuda vy udalilis (Lensky's aria) from Tchaikovsky's Eugene Onegin (1879)
Baritone Leo Nucci sings Eri tu from Verdi's Un Ballo in Maschera /A masked ball (1858)
The majority of bass-baritone roles can be found in the German repertory, Wagner especially. Although basses and bass-baritones will also sing some baritone roles if they have the high notes, baritone roles will usually hover in the higher notes for longer periods of time: this could strain a bass or bass-baritone voice. It's also a question of colour, bass voices tending to be darker and blacker than baritone voices. Roles such as Don Giovanni, Count Almaviva (in Mozart's Marriage of Figaro), Escamillo (in Bizet's Carmen) and Scarpia (in Puccini's Tosca) are often sung by either baritones, bass-baritones or basses.
Bass Boris Christoff sings the Death scene from Mussorgsky's Boris Godunov (1869)
In the next series of musical terms, we shall look at some common musical forms and structures used to create an opera.
Hmm could this be another reason I am drawn to Wagner?
ReplyDeleteThe castrato took the term "suffering for one's art" to an extreme! Glad as you put it "we tend not to castrate boys to sing opera" ! Even if using a mezzo or contraltos are a bit distracting, like Michele Losier as Siebel in Faust.
ReplyDeleteOne never knows what one will find in this blog. Last entry we had jazz singers, this time we get yodelling! Love it. Nothing like yodelling in the morning to make you smile. But it did illustrate your point.
Well done! As usual, thanks for taking the time to do this.
Are Contralto roles common in opera? Not sure have come across any yet?
ReplyDeleteAnd are trouser role parts mezzo sopranos generally?
Do counter tenors have quite short careers? (surely their voices can't last forever)His voice is v beautiful though
I couldn't bring myself to listen to the castrato link ( have heard it before) :-(
Sorry, my post seems to have turned into a listen of questions...Thanks Eddy, v interesting as always
lol at the yodelling ( you just added that cos you could, didn't you)
For a list of contralto roles in opera, see this wikipedia article:
Deletehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contralto#Contralto_roles_in_opera
This is quite interesting about the contralto voice:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/classicalmusic/7309084/Where-have-all-the-contraltos-gone.html
I can't think of many non-mezzo trouser parts, but it's important to recognise the difference between the singer and the role. For example, although Carmen is usually defined as a mezzo role, some sopranos have sung it because they have the notes in their voice to do it (similar to Scarpia, Escamillo etc as explained above). So although trouser roles may be written for mezzos, a soprano could still sing them: but the voice would probably sound lighter, and therefore younger. Some of the most common trouser roles are Cherubino in Mozart's The marriage of Figaro, Prince Orlofsky in Johann Strauss's operetta Die Fledermaus, Nicklausse in Offenbach's The Tales of Hoffmann, Octavian in Richard Strauss's Der Rosenkavalier, The Composer in Richard Strauss's Ariadne auf Naxos and Hansel in Humperdinck's Hansel and Gretel.
It's hard to talk about countertenors as they are a relatively recent phenomenon. The revival of the counter tenor came with Alfred Deller in the 50s/60s, followed in the next generation, by James Bowman. Since then, more male singers have chosen to sing as countertenors: Michael Chance, David Daniels, Philippe Jaroussky, Andreas Scholl, Max Cenci, to name but a few, and many more operas are now being written that use a countertenor voice.
Muchas Gracias for your quick response. It seems I have seen some contraltos, in MOF, Faust and Peter Grimes. Thank you, most informative .
ReplyDeleteHad no idea there was such a wide variety in opera voices. This was very helpful in identifying the different roles and why certain singers perform them.
ReplyDeleteWas going to ask about counter-tenors, but see your answer above. Will be interesting to watch what happens with them over time.
Would never have thought to compare opera to yodeling but it was very helpful! (altho not the little body shake of the yodeler!)
Slowly getting to understand the terms and the roles and what these very talented singers do. Another great blog. Thanks.